The results are in for the 2024 Patch Girl Scout Cookie Throwdown Poll, and while Thin Mints once again clinched the top spot, the real winners are the cherished memories of those who sold these iconic treats dating back to the 1950s.
Among the 710 Patch readers who participated in the informal poll, Thin Mints secured the lead with about 35.6 percent of the votes. Peanut Butter Patties (also known as Tagalongs) followed closely behind at approximately 27.4 percent, with Caramel deLites (Samoas) claiming the third spot at around 22.4 percent.
Yet, beyond the delicious debate over cookie preferences, it’s the heartfelt memories that stole the spotlight. Readers fondly recalled their experiences selling cookies, dating back to the 1950s, with one individual reminiscing about being the “Cookie Queen” in Weehawken, New Jersey.
Some shared tales of door-to-door sales, red wagons used for deliveries, and the joy of being a part of the Girl Scouts community. Others reflected on their roles as troop leaders, cookie moms, and the impact of scouting on building lasting friendships.
Thin Mints, described as “flavor nirvana,” remained a favorite, with one reader declaring them “heaven on earth.” However, the limited availability of Thin Mints was bemoaned by some, with one reader expressing sadness at the prospect of waiting another year to indulge in this annual treat.
The Raspberry Rally cookie, a limited-edition companion to Thin Mints, infused with fruity flavor, became a point of disappointment for some readers due to its absence this year. Others expressed their love for alternatives like Girl Scout S’mores and defended their cookie choices passionately.
While the poll showcased Thin Mints as the popular favorite, the real takeaway was the flood of memories and the sense of community associated with Girl Scout Cookies. The annual cookie sales season not only funds activities and camps but also creates lasting bonds and teaches valuable skills to girls.
As cookie sales continue until April, the Girl Scout Cookie Finder remains a helpful tool to connect with local troops or explore online sales opportunities. The 2024 Girl Scout Cookie season is not just about cookies; it’s about celebrating the rich tapestry of experiences and connections that have made Girl Scout Cookies a beloved tradition for generations.
