According to Patch reporter **Sarah Salvadore**, Barstool Sports founder **Dave Portnoy** made a stop in **West Windsor, New Jersey**, where he reviewed a local tomato pie spot and declared it a strong new contender. Portnoy visited **Papa’s Tomato Pies’ Robbinsville location**, which serves the well-known Trenton-style tomato pie, and gave it a notable rating during his ongoing “One Bite” pizza reviews.
In the review, Portnoy said the pizza was “really good” and scored it **8.1**, placing it among the better pies he has sampled in New Jersey. The visit drew attention locally because Portnoy’s ratings often influence public interest in pizza shops and can boost a restaurant’s profile significantly.
Papa’s Tomato Pies is widely recognized as one of the oldest pizzerias in the United States and is closely associated with the tomato pie tradition in the Trenton area. Portnoy’s stop in West Windsor added to the broader conversation around which local establishments best represent that style. His rating effectively positioned the shop as a serious challenger among New Jersey’s notable pizza destinations.
The article notes that Portnoy’s pizza reviews have built a large following online, with each stop often becoming a local event. In this case, his assessment gave renewed attention to a long-established regional favorite and highlighted the continued popularity of tomato pie in central New Jersey.
Source: **Sarah Salvadore, Patch**
facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61561607604274
twitter: https://x.com/cherryhillnt
Original article: https://patch.com/new-jersey/west-windsor/dave-portnoy-stops-west-windsor-crowns-new-tomato-pie-contender
